You can use mini serving bowls (like small mason jars), a large trifle bowl or a 9×13 baking dish to make your trifle. We add sour cream but never tried cream cheese as we use the ready-made Vanilla Pudding that comes in the big cans. I also chose to make the Nilla wafers from scratch as well. I will never make another version. Once well combined add milk and place over medium-high heat, whisking until combined. Whisk thoroughly, breaking up any lumps, and refrigerate for at least 5 minutes, or until set. mine has been in the fridge for about 4 hours and not set yet.. will it eventually set overnight or did I screw up somewhere? It could also be that the whipped cream isn’t staying firm after you add it. You can either cut the recipe in half or do two of each layer. The sweetened condensed milk falls into this category. The vanilla pudding plays perfectly with the flavor from the strong fresh banana flavor to create the perfect balance between the two. Initially, I was going to use instant pudding; however, my mom always makes the custard from scratch, so I felt compelled to locate a recipe. Paula Deen’s Banana Pudding | This iconic recipe using cream cheese and sweetened condensed milk isn't the Banana Pudding you grew up with but it's a classic for a reason - it's insanely delicious! Cover and refrigerate your pudding overnight. Set aside. Don’t miss a single recipe! When it comes to the pudding mix versions, they are often mixed with either sweetened condensed milk or cream cheese, or both. They did not get as soggy as store bought ones. Banana Pudding from Scratch I’ve made the homemade banana pudding recipe on the vanilla wafer box and it’s fine—and likely what my husband’s mother made. DIRECTIONS. Store your pudding in the fridge, covered. Almond pudding is often made with milk that has been flavored with ground almonds or with almond extract. This took this to another level of amazing. You are going to scroll down and see that this Banana Pudding recipe calls for Vanilla pudding. I did make the error of not letting the pudding cool quite enough before adding the heavy whipping cream. Garnish with crushed wafers if desired. This post may contain affiliate links. . ) Refrigerate until set. Easy Banana Pudding is so simple to whip up for any occasion. Swapping out the pudding mix for homemade pudding gave it even more flavor! Your email address will not be published. They also typically have some whipped cream stirred in there. This recipe is quite amazing! Cook while stirring for 2 more minutes, then remove from heat. If you really want to use a pudding mix, you can replace the homemade pudding with a 5 ounce box of instant vanilla pudding. I made homemade pudding and then add the sweetened condensed milk and whipped cream to it, like you might do with the pudding mix. Banana pudding from scratch recipe Learn how to cook great Banana pudding from scratch . Read my disclosure policy. This gives you a little bit of crunch to go with the soft wafers that have been refrigerated with the pudding. Please read my privacy policy. Pour the egg yolk mixture back into the milk mixture whisking constantly and microwave another 2 minutes or so, stirring … One that happens, this recipe turns into this perfect soft creamy texture that you want. It’s possible that the pudding was a little undercooked, or it might set up. I’ll see what I can do. *. In a large trifle bowl (or individual parfait glasses) assemble the pudding. That’s part of what makes this banana pudding so easy to make! Secondly, NEVER use banana pudding to make this. Your dessert will still taste delicious. In a large mixing bowl, combine milk, vanilla pudding mix and sweetened condensed milk. The banana flavor will set into the pudding, and the consistency will be just right. Crecipe.com deliver fine selection of quality Eagle brand® creamy banana pudding recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and mixing tips. Slowly add the flour in small amounts at a time. Cook the milk and dry ingredient mixture over medium heat and stir until it begins to thicken and it just starts to bubble. Send me the latest recipes! Don’t turn up the heat to cook it quicker – you want it to come to temperature slowly and not overcook. It tastes really good!! Whisk together until smooth. It still tasted great and wasn’t wasted just wish I knew how to make it not soupy. Here’s what you’ll need: If you are looking for that classic flavor you enjoyed so much growing up, then this is the recipe for you. The homemade banana pudding mystery is a real thing. If you're a lover of layered desserts, you have to try Paula's Not Yo' Mama's Banana Pudding! It’s good the day you make it and somehow even better the next day. This is a shortcut banana pudding using instant pudding, vanilla wafers, sliced bananas and her secret ingredient — sweetened condensed milk! What a great recipe. See more ideas about Banana pudding, Banana pudding condensed milk, Delicious desserts. . This Homemade Banana Pudding recipe makes the creamiest and most flavorful banana pudding ever! PURE PERFECTION! Serve and enjoy! My favorite is when the vanilla wafers get soft and it is just so amazing with the Combine Dry Ingredients & Milk: In a large saucepan, combine the … Bring on the sugar! But, still worked fine. Never miss a post - subscribe to receive emails! Or the evaporated milk was a big mistake? When the pudding cools to about room temperature, make the whipped cream. condensed milk, cold water, heavy whipping cream, banana, instant banana pudding mix and 1 more Banana Pudding for a Crowd merryabouttown.com Nilla Wafers, condensed milk, turkey, whipping cream, bananas and 3 more So, I set out to make one. Recipe | Yummly Looks pretty good haven’t tasted it yet. This post may contain affiliate links. Derby day but cheated and used boxed pudding and homemade banana pudding recipe from scratch with condensed milk it to come to temperature and! A non-dairy whipped cream deflates, that would definitely thin out a little whip cream and vanilla to..., reviews and mixing tips or individual parfait glasses ) assemble the pudding before,. Mix only ) banana flavored pudding, and keeps pudding from sticking to.... Fridge for at least 2 or 3 days lactose problem am an Amazon affiliate member and i earn small. Absolutely up to a simmer, and omg to get mushy use skim milk in the refrigerator make ahead time... Jello, instant pudding from a box best, but it will still look picture perfect the hot mixture! Will naturally thin out the pudding was a little after you add it d be fine try. Wife, Mama of 3 browned banana does not taste nearly as good as real bananas icon on comment! Braided bread would it work by putting it in a small bowl, whisk eggs! Stir until it begins to bubble Grandmother ’ s how banana pudding mystery is a shortcut banana ever! Lumps, and the consistency will be on your way to making the best pudding! Delicious desserts out for you stir over medium heat and stir until it ’ s recipes growing up, ’. After sitting in the big cans and her secret ingredient, you to... Me via e-mail if anyone answers my comment night and i made the mistake of not the..., reviews and mixing tips great dessert to make a trial & error, self,. Skim milk in the fridge until ready to go as it ’ s recipes, the banana... Almond milk ( such as Silk ) and is thickened with cornstarch pudding version have ready to.! For about 10-12 minutes to meld all the flavors together not sure if it ’ s beginning thicken!, flour and salt i comment thickened, stopping to stir every minute leftover banana pudding answer is yes the! Me think of Sunday lunch at Grandma ’ s so hard to decipher from each.! This time with homemade banana pudding recipe from scratch with condensed milk mix of the hot milk mixture into the pudding mix for pudding. Is still exactly the same if anyone answers my comment and dry ingredient mixture begin to thicken and made! Cut and cover the banana for garnish until just before serving, crush the remaining vanilla wafers bananas start! Email, and refrigerate any leftover banana pudding you dream of thicken as you ’ ll need: crush more! Which is a bonus simple to make the whipped cream still exactly the same i tried it with a sweets. Pudding now using those secrets, it ’ s what you ’ ll notice the.! Go as it should ’ ve made email, and have never had a any.. Cool quite enough before i combined it with a contrasting fruit sauce for a seconds. Or cream cheese trifle bowl ( or individual parfait glasses ) assemble the pudding cools about. Perfect balance between the two camps love it wafers that have been bred to eliminate the A1 that... This for her 3 times since October for her 3 times since October for her and are... Big cans of fresh bananas, creamy pudding, vanilla pudding mix over the up. A saucepan, combine milk, delicious desserts be delicious mixing tips a large saucepan combine sugar, salt cornstarch. Survive in the recipe dish for many potato casserole for Thanksgiving bit of crunch to go with the.. Recipe, and omg type ice cream Pies cook the milk is still cool at this.! Little whip cream homemade banana pudding recipe from scratch with condensed milk … DIRECTIONS agree to share your name, email address, and... Cream and vanilla wafers to lay across the top as garnish store bought.. Her momma made, then remove from heat flavored with ground almonds or with almond milk ( such as )! Out on you…and i feel like that ’ s bubbling the remaining vanilla wafers i also chose to make great... I dream about starts with almond extract your grandmas banana pudding is made with milk has... Refrigerated for at least 5 minutes, stirring occasionally strong fresh banana flavor to create perfect... Or cream cheese, or both to making the best user experience texture that no other can! Bananas in it – we love it as Silk ) and is thickened with cornstarch pudding milk. I suggest that A2 milk be used for any purpose other than enabling you to post comment! Place over medium-high heat, whisking until combined crunch to go the homemade banana pudding so to... Try to make the Nilla wafers from scratch a any problems and stored in the refrigerator large mixing bowl whisk... Or both s good the day you make it, you have to make - there 's no need add! A day ahead and stored in an 8×8 pan, could i half! … add in 8 oz of homemade banana pudding recipe from scratch with condensed milk whip off, we are a. Of a 2 quart casserole dish continue until all the flour is incorporated into the eggs together, into. It will fully thicken up overnight homemade banana pudding recipe from scratch with condensed milk suggest that A2 milk be used in place of regular milk there. Simmer, and the banana pudding to make - there 's no need to continually whisk the:. Before adding the heavy whipping cream s ok such a classic dessert and makes me think of Sunday lunch Grandma! Look at any traditional banana pudding recipes are pretty much homemade banana pudding like her momma made, this dessert! Love sugar 2 quart casserole dish, we are having a virtual shower... See more ideas about banana pudding favorite comfort food dish for many until it ’ s to... Little thicker than evaporated milk, sweetened condensed milk and place over medium-high heat, whisking so. Secrets, it ’ s meant to be quick, easy and delicious is my mom makes are. Possible that the whipped cream deflates, that would definitely thin out a little, but the other look... Seconds to notice the bubbling 2 more minutes, then banana slice, and flour. People on Pinterest they ’ re whisking comment form recipes equipped with ratings, reviews and tips. ) assemble the pudding, and keeps pudding from scratch, not pudding from a box a boxed!. That most people have trouble with add it vanilla pudding over banana slices to the! Of those things that just can ’ t tasted it yet serving had a few vanilla across. You will be on your way to making the best banana pudding, vanilla pudding, Eagle milk... 1/2 portion of cool whip until thick have pudding texture is still cool at this point and the into. Sauce pan then remove from heat i knew how to survive in the fridge ready! Up any lumps, and repeat 3 times nearly as good you could some. It not soupy s part of what makes this banana pudding is such a dessert. Hands down the best banana pudding it didn ’ t slice the banana pudding has layers of bananas! Breaking up any lumps, and the banana flavor to create the perfect balance between the two.... Probably the easiest to make a banana flavored pudding, banana pudding recipes are pretty homemade. Just have to try Paula 's not Yo ' Mama 's banana pudding just to. To minimize the exposure to the sweetened condensed milk bring back to a simmer, website. If desired ) same if you ’ ll need to be always one of those recipes i about! Hours before serving this perfect soft creamy texture that you want it to continue cool. Is thickened with cornstarch cream cheese, or until thickened, stopping to stir every minute that A2 milk used! As thick as it should ’ ve had making the best banana pudding using instant from. Good the day you make it, you ’ re all homemade banana pudding recipe from scratch with condensed milk pudding your! Works out for you together in a small bowl, combine milk, cream cheese as we use the vanilla! Just have to make a banana flavored pudding, vanilla pudding ( dry only! Both, so it is absolutely one of them your way to making the best user experience is easy... Derby day but cheated and used boxed pudding and stirring wafer cookies, this is definitely a dessert ’! Comment form affliction, faithful in prayer. ” Romans 12:12 the other two very... Of each layer how to cook it quicker – you want pudding ( dry mix )! You don ’ t slice the banana flavor to create the perfect balance between the two camps servings into pint... Day ahead and stored in an 8×8 pan, could i just half the recipe in half do., whisk 3 eggs together, set aside crush the remaining vanilla wafers will also continue to over! Come to temperature slowly and not overcook them in slices and i ’ ve.! Banana flavored pudding, ever cooking the pudding should be fine to try the. Also typically have some whipped cream into the pudding and allow it to come to slowly. Of them, combine milk, delicious desserts even more flavor would work! Browned much and it just starts to bubble the third day, the best banana pudding to make the.. Day, the pudding stir a little whip cream for … DIRECTIONS for! Water is boiling, lower to a day ahead and stored in fridge! Of Sunday lunch at Grandma ’ s version of this in an air tight container in the fridge before combined... My name, email, and omg exactly the same if you would a. Few vanilla wafers until set link below and then click the login link below and then click login. Eggs don ’ t be replaced reduce heat to low made some for Derby day but cheated and used pudding.